
The Big 12 Championship Game: What does it do?
Sunday, November 30th, 2008This is not in favor of either Texas, Texas Tech, Oklahoma, Missouri or any other team.
But seriously, what does the Big 12 Championship game do? For anyone? Ever?
Case in point: This year, three of the best teams in the country are all in the same division of the same conference. Instead of deciding who is best in the conference, the BCS decides which one of the three should play Missouri. And if Missouri does pull off the upset, sure, they earn a bowl bearth, but they still aren’t in the top three of the Big 12 teams, thereby accomplishing virtually nothing.
If you’re an Oklahoma fan, it’s not a good game either. Kansas City is a snake pit for OU. See 2003 vs. Kansas State in Kansas City. The Sooners were ranked an overwhelming #1 and got beat. Then they still went to the national title game, amidst controversy and argument, and lost to LSU. So what did it do for them?
Then there was 2001 in Dallas, where Texas lost to Colorado. That was pre-BCS as well, but a loss to the Buffaloes cost the Longhorns a solid shot at the national title game.
Additionally, Big Ten and Pac-10 teams have an easier route to the national championship because they don’t have conference championship games. Those teams use the BCS ranking to their advantage, and it works. They get in, while the extra game gives critics of Big 12 teams more ammunition to eliminate them from national title contention.
This year it’s the “who gets to play Missouri on practically their home field in cold weather?” bowl. What could this game decide, other than possibly eliminate a team who is deserving of their BCS ranking? If OU wins, it won’t be shocking. If OU wins by a lot of points, it could help them. If they win by a few points, it could hurt them and/or help Texas.
Mack Brown has said that too many times, polls eliminate good teams, rather than promote the ones who are deserving. If Oklahoma loses to Missouri, Texas fans will have reason to cheer. But, similar to what Brown said, that scenario eliminates a team instead of promoting them.
The game may make the conference money, give them tons of exposure, give fans an extra game to go to and cheer for, but at what cost?
